Florida Car Accident Lawyer
After a car accident, medical appointments, a damaged vehicle and missed work can compete for your attention. If the other driver disputes fault or your symptoms change over time, you may also be unsure what to tell an insurer or which records to keep.
At Rafferty Domnick Cunningham & Yaffa, we review the collision evidence, relevant insurance policies and the effect of your injuries on daily life. We can explain how injury claims, insurance benefits and property damage issues fit together, and help you identify the information needed for the next step.
Have Questions About Car Accidents?
Call us or request a case review by our experts.
Medical care and insurance benefits involve different questions
Get appropriate medical attention and tell your providers about the collision and your symptoms. Florida personal injury protection, or PIP, is a limited first-party benefit system for people covered by the statute. Initial services generally must occur within 14 days for medical benefits, and eligibility, provider requirements and an emergency-medical-condition determination affect the available benefits.
PIP does not necessarily pay every expense or resolve a claim against a responsible driver. Liability coverage, uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage and health coverage may present additional questions. We examine the actual policies and facts rather than assuming that the other driver’s insurer will pay your bills as treatment occurs.
Sources: Florida personal injury protection benefits; Florida motor-vehicle tort thresholds.
Evidence can resolve a disputed crash account
Preserve photographs, witness contact details and the report information you receive. Tell us about dashcams, nearby businesses, intersections or vehicles that may have captured the collision. Footage can be overwritten, and vehicles may be repaired before an inspection is considered.
The investigation may compare physical damage, roadway conditions, traffic controls, witness accounts and available electronic evidence. In an appropriate case, phone records or expert reconstruction may help address a disputed account. Access to another person’s private records must follow the proper legal process.
A citation, an insurer’s statement or one person’s recollection does not always settle civil responsibility. We assess the evidence as a whole and explain what additional information could change the evaluation.
Sources: Florida relevant evidence; Florida comparative fault.
How Could Car Accidents Affect Your Legal Options?
Call us or request a case review by our experts.
The type of collision helps direct the investigation
A rear-end collision may raise questions about stopping distance, traffic conditions and vehicle defects. A turning or intersection crash may require a closer look at signal phases, sight lines and the movements of each vehicle. A multi-vehicle collision can involve separate impacts and disputed responsibility for particular injuries.
Distracted driving, impaired driving and unsafe speed are possible explanations, not assumptions to insert into every case. We focus on the evidence supporting the actual collision. If a commercial vehicle or a defective component was involved, additional parties and legal theories may need investigation.
Documenting losses means looking beyond the first bill
Medical records help connect the collision to the diagnosis, treatment and continuing limitations. Wage records, job duties and medical restrictions may establish missed earnings and longer-term work effects. Future care and reduced earning capacity may require qualified expert support.
Florida’s motor-vehicle tort rules can limit recovery of pain-and-suffering damages unless a statutory injury threshold is met. A diagnosis alone does not answer every legal question. We review permanency, the treatment record, other relevant evidence and the losses recoverable under the applicable law.
Keep receipts and correspondence and explain the daily activities affected by your injuries. Avoid treating a settlement advertisement as a valuation of your own claim; responsibility, coverage and documented losses differ from case to case.
Sources: Florida motor-vehicle tort thresholds; Florida comparative fault.
Deadlines and comparative fault can affect recovery
For Florida negligence claims accruing after March 24, 2023, the general filing period is two years. Other claims and exceptions can involve different rules. Insurance notices and benefit requirements may need attention much earlier, so waiting until treatment is complete can create problems.
Under Florida’s current modified comparative-fault rule, a claimant more than 50 percent responsible for their own harm is barred from recovery in covered negligence actions. Lesser fault can reduce damages. We review applicability and the evidence rather than accepting an insurer’s percentage as conclusive.
Sources: Florida limitation periods; Florida Chapter 2023-15 (HB 837), application provisions; Florida comparative fault.
How we can help with your car accident claim
Bring the report number, insurer correspondence, available photographs and treatment information. We can review potential coverage, identify evidence that needs preservation and explain what a claim would require. If you have received a release or settlement offer, its scope deserves review before you sign.
We develop the evidence of responsibility and loss, address supported disputes with insurers and prepare for litigation when appropriate. Ask who will handle your case, how updates will be provided and how fees and expenses are addressed in the written agreement.
Professional Recognition
Our attorneys’ credentials, honors and professional service include:
Recognition applies to the named attorney and the stated year or period.
Related Practice Resources
Florida Car Accident FAQs
These answers provide general information. The facts, dates and law governing an individual claim require a separate review.
Does Florida PIP coverage mean I cannot bring a car accident lawsuit?
No. Personal injury protection and a liability claim address different questions. PIP provides specified benefits under Florida’s no-fault system, subject to statutory and policy requirements. A claim against another responsible party requires its own analysis of fault, damages, coverage and any applicable threshold for noneconomic damages.
Florida’s PIP statute includes a requirement for initial services and care within 14 days, with additional rules affecting benefits. That insurance timing is separate from the time to file a lawsuit. Prompt medical attention should follow your condition, and counsel can review the policies and treatment timeline rather than assume that PIP pays every loss or prevents all further recovery.
Sources: Florida personal injury protection benefits; Florida motor-vehicle tort thresholds.
When can pain and suffering be claimed after a Florida car crash?
Florida’s motor-vehicle no-fault law can require a qualifying injury before certain noneconomic damages are recoverable against an otherwise exempt defendant. The statutory categories include specified significant or permanent injuries and death. Whether the threshold applies and is met depends on the claim and medical evidence, not simply on the size of a repair bill.
Keep records of diagnosis, treatment, limitations and prognosis. A physician’s opinion may be relevant, but the defense can dispute permanence or causation. Economic losses and insurance benefits involve separate rules. The evaluation should distinguish these issues rather than tell every crash victim that pain automatically establishes a right to a particular payment.
Sources: Florida motor-vehicle tort thresholds; Florida civil jury instructions, negligence and compensatory damages.
What if I was a passenger and do not know which driver caused the crash?
A passenger can have a claim even when responsibility between drivers is disputed. The investigation should examine each driver’s conduct and all relevant coverage instead of accepting the first account offered. Liability must still be supported by evidence, and more than one party may have contributed to the collision.
Provide the vehicles’ and drivers’ identifying information, witness contacts, photographs and any reports available. Preserve your own treatment history and describe what you actually observed without guessing about events you could not see. Florida’s comparative-fault and insurance rules can affect how the claim is presented, so passenger status alone does not resolve every coverage or damages issue.
Sources: Florida comparative fault; Florida personal injury protection benefits; Florida civil jury instructions, negligence and compensatory damages.
Should I sign a car accident release before all my treatment is finished?
A release should be reviewed before you sign because it may permanently resolve claims connected to the crash. An offer can seem adequate for current bills while leaving uncertainty about future care, work restrictions or other losses. You do not need to assume that an early offer accounts for those consequences.
Ask which parties and claims would be released, whether other coverage is affected and what medical information supports the valuation. Keeping a claim under review does not pause its filing deadline. A lawyer can explain the choices and risks based on the actual documents; no general webpage can determine whether a specific settlement is appropriate for you.
Sources: Florida civil jury instructions, negligence and compensatory damages; Florida limitation periods.
How long do I have to bring a Florida car accident claim?
Florida generally allows two years for ordinary negligence claims accruing after March 24, 2023. Earlier claims and different legal theories can follow different rules. The deadline therefore cannot be calculated from the page title alone; the incident date, when the claim accrued, the defendant and the legal basis all matter.
Have the timeline reviewed promptly and bring any correspondence, incident reports and prior claim documents. Negotiating with an insurer does not by itself extend the filing period. In a car accident matter involving death, medical treatment, a public entity or a defective product, additional or different timing requirements may apply. Waiting for treatment to finish can put a claim at risk.
Sources: Florida limitation periods; Florida Chapter 2023-15 (HB 837), application provisions.
Can I recover if I am blamed for part of the car accident?
You may still have a claim, but comparative fault can reduce or bar recovery. Under Florida’s current general negligence framework, a claimant found more than 50 percent responsible for their own harm cannot recover. The statute contains exceptions, including for actions based on medical negligence, so the rule must be matched to the actual claim.
An insurer’s accusation is not a final allocation of fault. For a car accident, accounts of what happened should be compared with physical evidence, records and witness testimony. Preserve facts that support or contradict each explanation rather than accepting a percentage during an informal conversation. The applicable version of the law and any special rules also need review.
Sources: Florida comparative fault; Florida civil jury instructions, negligence and compensatory damages.
What losses can a Florida car accident claim address?
A supported injury claim may include medical expenses, lost earnings, impaired future earning ability and noneconomic harm such as pain or loss of enjoyment of life. The categories and amounts depend on the law and evidence; a serious diagnosis does not create an automatic settlement value. Responsibility and causation must also be established.
For car accident cases, useful documentation may include crash photographs, witness details, insurance notices, treatment bills and missed-work records. Future needs should be supported by appropriate medical or other expert evidence, with clear assumptions about their duration and cost. Prior conditions, other causes, fault and applicable coverage can affect the analysis. A result reported in another case is not a valuation of your claim.
Sources: Florida civil jury instructions, negligence and compensatory damages; Florida comparative fault.
What records should I keep for a car accident case?
Keep original records that show the event, the injury and its consequences. For a car accident case, useful material may include crash photographs, witness details, insurance notices, treatment bills and missed-work records. Save dates and contact information, and identify who may hold other evidence. Do not alter records, fill gaps with guesses or discard material because it seems unfavorable.
You generally may request your own medical and billing records from covered providers under HIPAA, subject to limited exceptions. Litigation can also provide procedures for obtaining relevant information from other parties. Your lawyer can identify preservation and discovery steps, but a personal request does not guarantee that every record will remain available indefinitely. Explain missing information early so the review can address it.
Sources: HHS: health information individuals may access; Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, October 1, 2026.
Will my car accident case have to go to trial?
Not every claim reaches trial, but no one can promise settlement at the beginning. The parties may resolve a supported dispute through negotiation or mediation. If material issues remain, the court’s procedures govern discovery, motions and trial. A refusal to settle does not establish who will ultimately win.
In a car accident case, the decision requires an assessment of the evidence, legal defenses, documented losses and the terms of any offer. Ask what the release covers and whether it ends future claims connected to the injury. Preparing the case carefully helps you evaluate those choices; it does not guarantee a verdict or force an insurer to pay a particular amount.
Sources: Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, October 1, 2026; Florida civil jury instructions, negligence and compensatory damages; Florida court-ordered mediation.
Does a preexisting condition defeat my car accident claim?
No, a preexisting condition does not automatically defeat a claim for an injury or aggravation caused by someone else. The evidence must distinguish the condition’s earlier effects from the harm caused or worsened by the event. The applicable damages instructions address aggravation and situations in which effects cannot readily be separated.
For a car accident case, provide an accurate history, including earlier symptoms, treatment and daily limitations. Medical records before and after the event can help qualified professionals assess the change. Concealing earlier care makes that assessment harder. Neither a prior diagnosis nor a new symptom alone resolves causation; the timeline, examination and other evidence must be considered together.
Sources: Florida civil jury instructions, negligence and compensatory damages; HHS: health information individuals may access.
Need Help With a Case Involving Car Accidents?
Call us or request a case review by our experts.
