Florida Auto Insurance Bad Faith Lawyers

An auto insurance dispute can leave you facing unpaid losses or uncertainty about a claim made against you. You may have a denial, a disputed settlement or conflicting explanations about which coverage applies.

At Rafferty Domnick Cunningham & Yaffa, we review the policy, collision and claim history to identify the legal issues involved. We examine settlement communications and the insurer’s conduct, then explain whether the circumstances concern benefits, coverage, a potential bad-faith claim or more than one issue.

Have Questions About Bad Faith – Auto Insurance?

Call us or request a case review by our experts.

RDCY law firm shareholders

Whose policy and which coverage are involved?

The analysis begins with the insured, claimant, coverage and requested benefit. A dispute over collision coverage or uninsured motorist benefits is not identical to a liability insurer’s handling of a claim against its insured. PIP benefits also have their own statutory framework.

Bring the policy and endorsements, not only the insurance card. We examine coverage questions alongside the facts of the collision and the loss. A contractual dispute may need resolution before a separate bad-faith claim can proceed.

Sources: Florida insurer civil remedies; Florida personal injury protection benefits.

Settlement communications can be central evidence

Liability matters may turn on the information available to the insurer, the opportunity to settle and the terms communicated by the parties. Demands, supporting medical information, coverage disclosures, proposed releases and responses should be preserved in full.

We reconstruct the chronology to determine what was known, what remained reasonably necessary and how each party responded. A demand’s deadline alone does not establish an insurer’s liability. The content and circumstances of the communication matter.

If you are the insured facing a claim that may exceed coverage, preserve communications from the carrier and defense counsel. The potential exposure and available protection need careful legal review rather than an assumption that the policy limit ends every issue.

Sources: Florida insurer civil remedies; Florida relevant evidence.

How Could Bad Faith – Auto Insurance Affect Your Legal Options?

Call us or request a case review by our experts.

RDCY law firm shareholders

Florida’s bad-faith rules include opportunities to cure

Section 624.155 contains a 60-day notice-and-cure process for statutory claims. It also provides a 90-day tender protection for liability-insurance claims when the insurer receives actual notice with sufficient evidence supporting the amount. These provisions do not operate identically in every dispute.

The law also states that mere negligence alone does not establish bad faith and addresses good-faith conduct by insureds, claimants and their representatives. We evaluate the whole record, including information requests and settlement terms, rather than treating a missed demand as an automatic claim.

Sources: Florida insurer civil remedies; Florida unfair insurance practices.

The damages inquiry follows the legal claim

Unpaid policy benefits, an excess exposure and other claimed losses require different proof. A bad-faith allegation does not make every requested category recoverable. Florida law includes specific restrictions, including a prohibition on punitive damages in the excess automobile-liability action described in section 627.737(4).

We can review how the insurer’s conduct allegedly caused the loss and which remedy the applicable law permits. Previous firm results cannot supply that missing connection or predict the amount recoverable in a new matter.

Sources: Florida insurer civil remedies; Florida motor-vehicle tort thresholds.

Timing should be reviewed before the underlying matter ends

Coverage deadlines, underlying injury deadlines, notice requirements and the accrual of a potential bad-faith claim are separate questions. Do not assume that an open claim file or a pending complaint suspends all time limits.

Bring the dates of the collision, notice, demands, responses and any judgment or settlement. We can identify which requirements need attention now and which issues depend on a later determination.

Sources: Florida limitation periods; Florida insurer civil remedies.

How we can help with an auto insurance dispute

We examine the complete policy and claim record, identify missing communications and evaluate the legal significance of the insurer’s conduct. The investigation may also require understanding the underlying injury and settlement opportunity.

Ask about the proposed scope of representation, who will communicate with the insurer and how fees and expenses are handled. A careful review should clarify your options without promising that every disagreement becomes a bad-faith recovery.

Professional Recognition

Our attorneys’ credentials, honors and professional service include:

Lawdragon professional profileFlorida Super Lawyers Top 100 — 2026Miami Super Lawyers Top 100 — 2026
  • Fred Cunningham — Board Certified Civil Trial Lawyer, The Florida Bar. Source
  • Fred Cunningham — Best Lawyers “Lawyer of the Year” for Insurance Law, West Palm Beach, 2026. Source
  • Fred Cunningham — Top 5 Florida Super Lawyers for Personal Injury Plaintiff, 2026. Source
  • Sean Domnick, Nicole Kruegel, Fred Cunningham, Troy Rafferty and Gregory Yaffa — selected to the 2025 Lawdragon 500 Leading Plaintiff Consumer Lawyers. Source
  • Fred Cunningham — President of the Florida Justice Association, 2011–2012; Fellow of the American College of Coverage and Extracontractual Counsel. Source
  • Gregory Yaffa — Florida Justice Association Jon E. Krupnick Award, 2019. Source
  • Gregory Yaffa — inducted into the American Board of Trial Advocates, 2025. Source
  • Gregory Yaffa — lecturer on insurance bad-faith strategies at the Florida Justice Association’s 2026 Winter Ski Seminar. Source

Recognition applies to the named attorney and the stated year or period.

Published Articles by Our Attorneys

Explore our attorneys’ published work on this practice and broader issues in civil litigation, access to the courts and legal representation.

Some publishers may require a subscription.

Our Videos and Social Posts

NOTABLE RESULTS

The following catastrophic injury and motor-vehicle results reflect our attorneys’ broader litigation experience:

$31,000,000 catastrophic injury result · $13,000,000 motor-vehicle verdict

Read more about these results

Our catastrophic injury results include a $31,000,000 result in Fort Lauderdale. This example reflects our broader injury practice. Read the published result.

Our shareholder Troy Rafferty’s trial experience includes a $13,000,000 motor-vehicle verdict. Read the published result.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Each case is different and must be evaluated on its own facts.

WHAT OUR CLIENTS SAY

Here is what clients have shared about working with us, excerpted from their five-star Google reviews. Reviews reflect individual experiences.

“Natasha and Sean have been amazing to work with!”

— Brett

Read Brett’s review on Google

“I highly recommend Fred Cunningham, whose representation skillfully brought a high stakes litigation to a successful ending.”

— David

Read David’s review on Google

Florida Auto Insurance Bad Faith FAQs

These answers provide general information. The facts, dates and law governing an individual claim require a separate review.

Can my own auto insurer and the other driver’s insurer present different issues?

Yes. A first-party benefits claim and a third-party liability claim arise from different relationships and obligations. PIP, collision, uninsured-motorist and liability coverages should not be treated as one interchangeable policy benefit. The insurer involved and the coverage being requested affect the available process.

Bring all relevant policies, claim numbers, demands and denial letters. Florida’s PIP statute sets requirements for that coverage, while the civil-remedy framework addresses specified insurer conduct under its own conditions. A disagreement about vehicle value does not automatically follow the same route as an insurer’s handling of a liability settlement demand. Identifying the claim correctly is the first step.

Sources: Florida personal injury protection benefits; Florida insurer civil remedies.

Does an auto insurer owe every amount above its policy limit?

No. An excess loss does not automatically establish a bad-faith claim or make the insurer responsible for every amount demanded. The analysis depends on a legally supported breach of the insurer’s obligations, causation and the applicable claim framework. Policy limits and liability evidence are only part of that analysis.

Review the settlement opportunities, information supplied, communications and actions taken by the insurer and other participants. Florida law includes provisions affecting liability-claim handling and a specific restriction on punitive damages in certain excess claims against motor-vehicle insurers. The outcome cannot be predicted from the size of an injury or the difference between a demand and the limit.

Sources: Florida insurer civil remedies; Florida motor-vehicle tort thresholds.

What is the 90-day tender provision for a Florida liability insurer?

Florida’s statute provides that a bad-faith action involving liability insurance does not lie in specified circumstances if the insurer tenders the lesser of the policy limits or amount demanded within 90 days after actual notice accompanied by sufficient evidence. The exact trigger and application require review of the actual submission.

A demand’s delivery, supporting material and amount can matter. The provision should not be confused with the separate 60-day Civil Remedy Notice framework or with a universal deadline for every auto benefit. Preserve the full demand package and insurer response. Counsel can explain how the statutory provisions interact without assuming that a calendar calculation alone proves or defeats every claim.

Sources: Florida insurer civil remedies; Florida unfair insurance practices.

Can the way a claimant presents a demand affect an auto bad-faith case?

Yes. Florida’s statute addresses good-faith conduct by insureds, claimants and their representatives in furnishing information, making demands, setting deadlines and attempting settlement. The parties’ actual conduct can therefore matter when evaluating a claimed failure to resolve a liability claim.

Keep accurate copies of demands, medical and loss support, requests for information and responses. Artificially incomplete information or an unexplained deadline should not be assumed to create an automatic right to excess damages. The focus should remain on a supported claim and the opportunity to evaluate and resolve it. A lawyer can assess the facts and statutory requirements before advising that a bad-faith action is available.

Sources: Florida insurer civil remedies; Florida civil jury instructions, negligence and compensatory damages.

Does a dispute over car repairs prove auto-insurance bad faith?

No. A repair or valuation disagreement may be a contract dispute without satisfying the separate requirements for bad faith. The policy’s coverage, deductibles, exclusions and valuation terms must be compared with estimates, inspections and the insurer’s explanation. A higher estimate alone does not establish unlawful conduct.

Preserve photographs, repair records and all estimates, including those you disagree with. Ask which policy provision supports the adjustment and document the response. Florida’s unfair-practices statute identifies specified conduct, while the civil-remedy statute governs additional requirements. The appropriate next step depends on the actual coverage and claim history rather than a presumption that every reduced payment is actionable bad faith.

Sources: Florida unfair insurance practices; Florida insurer civil remedies.

Should I preserve the whole auto claim file or only the denial letter?

Preserve the whole file that is available to you. A denial letter shows a stated decision, but the chronology can explain what information the insurer had, what it requested and how it responded to settlement or payment opportunities. Those details may be central to distinguishing a benefits dispute from a supported bad-faith allegation.

Keep the policy, endorsements, demands, medical or repair support, communications and dates of delivery. Identify missing material without altering the record. Counsel can evaluate any additional information available through the applicable procedures. A selective excerpt may omit context important to either side, so the review should test the full history rather than begin with a conclusion.

Sources: Florida insurer civil remedies; Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, October 1, 2026.

Does a denied auto-insurance claim automatically establish bad faith?

No. A coverage dispute, an incorrect decision and a legally actionable bad-faith claim are different questions. Florida’s civil-remedy statute does not treat mere negligence as bad faith. The policy, claim history, insurer’s conduct and applicable prerequisites must be examined before deciding which remedy may be available.

For auto-insurance, the review should include the relevant coverage, settlement demands, supporting evidence and insurer responses. Identify the insurer’s stated reason and compare it with the policy and information supplied. A denial letter may reveal a contractual dispute, a need for additional evidence or conduct warranting further investigation. It does not by itself prove entitlement to damages beyond policy benefits.

Sources: Florida insurer civil remedies; Florida unfair insurance practices.

What records should I keep for an auto-insurance dispute?

Keep the complete policy and endorsements, the claim submission, all decisions and a dated record of communications. For auto-insurance, also preserve the relevant coverage, settlement demands, supporting evidence and insurer responses. The objective is to show what was requested, what the insurer received, why it acted and how the decision affected you.

Retain original documents rather than only summaries or screenshots of selected passages. If information is missing, identify who holds it and when it was requested. Florida’s insurance-practices provisions and litigation discovery rules can make the chronology important, but a recordkeeping problem does not automatically prove bad faith. A complete file helps distinguish policy obligations from separate allegations about claim handling.

Sources: Florida unfair insurance practices; Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, October 1, 2026.

What is a Civil Remedy Notice in a Florida auto-insurance case?

A Civil Remedy Notice is a statutory step for specified Florida insurance civil-remedy claims. It must provide the required information and give the insurer the applicable opportunity to cure. The general statutory framework includes a 60-day notice period, but the requirements and available claim depend on the circumstances.

A notice is not a substitute for proving coverage, breach or other required elements. It also does not mean every filing deadline is automatically extended. Have the specific policy, conduct and proposed remedy reviewed before treating a form submission as sufficient. In property-insurance cases, an additional statutory prerequisite can apply before damages beyond the contract may be pursued.

Sources: Florida insurer civil remedies; Florida property-insurer bad-faith prerequisite.

How should I evaluate an offer to resolve an auto-insurance dispute?

Review both the amount and the legal effect of the proposed agreement. An offer may address only policy benefits or may require a broader release of related claims. The terms, evidence and available remedies matter, including whether any additional statutory prerequisites have been met. A payment does not automatically establish or eliminate every bad-faith issue.

Ask which claims are released, how disputed amounts are calculated and what deadlines remain while negotiations continue. Keep the offer and correspondence. The decision should be based on the policy and documented conduct rather than a general expectation of punitive damages or a result obtained in another case. A lawyer can explain the tradeoffs in the actual documents.

Sources: Florida insurer civil remedies; Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, October 1, 2026.

Need Help With a Case Involving Bad Faith – Auto Insurance?

Call us or request a case review by our experts.

RDCY law firm shareholders